Privacy as Public Good – A Comparative Assessment of the Challenge for CoronApps in Latin America

Authors

  • Kim Barker Open University Law School http://orcid.org/0000-0003-4446-3480
  • Enrique Uribe-Jongbloed Universidad Externado de Colombia, Bogotá, Colombia
  • Tobias Scholz Universität Siegen, NRW, Germany

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.19164/jltt.v1i1.1006

Abstract

 Much of the reporting of the tracing apps, tracking programmes, and privacy concerns during the developmental processes and the initial stages of the Covid-19 pandemic have focussed on pitting digital rights and privacy against public health interests. Undoubtedly, there is best practice in establishing a tracing app to respond to Covid-19 while the work of civil society and NGOs in scrutinising the apps in various nations is vitally important and provides the core analysis of the scope of the data to be collated and retained. The holding to account of tracing systems and governments in utilising technology that is by its very nature invasive is vital in protecting digital rights. In times of crisis in particular, accountability is incredibly important to ensure that digital rights are not pushed aside in light of other concerns.To balance digital rights and privacy, and public health, accountability and transparency are essential – the scrutiny of the track and trace systems in Germany, the UK, and Colombia is therefore undertaken in this paper, which questions from interdisciplinary perspectives the scrutiny, accountability, and privacy concerns in each nation’s app before offering some conclusions and recommendations for the improvement and development of privacy and digital rights in Latin America. The conclusions offered here highlight good practice and outline the need for a holistic consideration of tracing systems, rather than advocating for a ‘one size fits all approach’ by positioning privacy as a public good, rather than an opponent of technological tracing systems.

Author Biography

Kim Barker, Open University Law School

Dr Kim Barker is a Senior Lecturer in law at the Open University Law School, specialising in internet law (including online violence against women) and intellectual property law (copyright, and digital content).

References

Morgan Lewis, ‘Coronavirus v. GDPR: Suspending Data Privacy Protection During Civil Crisis – The eData Guide to GDPR’ (JD Supra, 10 March 2020) <https://www.jdsupra.com/legalnews/coronavirus-v-gdpr-suspending-data-85584/> accessed 22 July 2020.

Ministry of Health, ‘CoronApp – Colombia, the application to know the evolution of the coronavirus in the country’ (Ministry of Health, 7 March 2020) <https://www.minsalud.gov.co/Paginas/CoronApp.aspx> accessed 22 July 2020.

Yadira Trujillo, ‘Gobierno de Ecuador presenta la 'app' Salud EC para acceder a una evaluación del covid-19 y recibir información’ (El Comercio, 25 March 2020) <https://www.elcomercio.com/actualidad/coronavirus-app-salud-ecuador-telemedicina.html> (accessed 22 July 2020).

International Law Firm Alliance, ‘The legal implications of Contact Tracing in Chile’ (Abdala & CIA Abogados, 29 May 2020) <https://diazreus.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/06/LATAM_contact-tracing.pdf> accessed 22 July 2020.

Geert Hofstede, Gert Jan Hofstede and Michael Minkov, Cultures and Organizations: Software of the Mind (McGraw-Hill 2010).

Nelson Arteaga and Liliana Onofre, ‘La protección a la privacidad en América Latina’ in Karina Ansolabehere, Francisco Valdés Ugalde & Daniel Vásquez (eds) Entre el pesimismo y la esperanza: Los derechos humanos en América Latina.Metodología para su estudio y medición (FLACSO-México 2015), 384.

Merten Reglitz, ‘The Human Right to Free Internet Access’ (2020) Journal of Applied Philosophy Vol 3&(2) 314.

Open Rights Group, ‘Joint Civil Society Statement: States use of Digital Surveillance Technologies to Fight Pandemic Must Respect Human Rights’ (Open Rights Group, 2 April 2020) <https://www.openrightsgroup.org/publications/joint-civil-society-statement-states-use-of-digital-surveillance-technologies-to-fight-pandemic-must-respect-human-rights/> accessed 22 July 2020.

Simon Chandler, ‘Coronavirus Could Infect Privacy and Civil Liberties Forever’ (Forbes, 23 March 2020) <https://www.forbes.com/sites/simonchandler/2020/03/23/coronavirus-could-infect-privacy-and-civil-liberties-forever/> accessed 22 July 2020.

Joshua A.T. Fairfield and Christoph Engel, ‘Privacy as a Public Good’ (2015) 65 Duke L.J. 385.

Human Rights Watch, ‘Ecuador: Privacy at Risk with Covid-19 Surveillance’ (Human Rights Watch, 1 July 2020) <https://www.hrw.org/news/2020/07/01/ecuador-privacy-risk-covid-19-surveillance#> accessed 22 July 2020.

Assemblea Nacional, ‘Gabriela Rivadaneira will promote the data protection law’ (12 July 2016) <https://www.asambleanacional.gob.ec/es/noticia/45016-gabriela-rivadeneira-impulsara-ley-de-proteccion-de> accessed 23 July 2020.

Luis Enriquez Álvarez, ‘Paradigmas de la protección de datos personales en Ecuador. Análisis del proyecto

de Ley Orgánica de Protección a los Derechos a la Intimidad y Privacidad sobre los Datos Personales’ (2017) Foro Revista de Derecho (27) 60.

Human Rights Watch, ‘Ecuador: Privacy at Risk with Covid-19 Surveillance’ (Human Rights Watch, 1 July 2020) <https://www.hrw.org/news/2020/07/01/ecuador-privacy-risk-covid-19-surveillance#> accessed 22 July 2020.

Gonzalo Salano, ‘Ecuador uses technology to fight COVID-19’ (AP, 16 April 2020) <https://apnews.com/516d5ddc49e3436c8681356a640c6a46> accessed 22 July 2020.

Christian Scholz and Volker Stein, Interkulturelle Wettbewerbsstrategien (Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht 2013).

Caroline Brogan, ‘COVID-19 contact tracing apps: 8 privacy questions governments should ask’ (Imperial College News, 2 April 2020) <https://www.imperial.ac.uk/news/196656/covid19-contact-tracing-apps-privacy-questions/> accessed 23 July 2020.

Paul Schwartz, ‘Illusions of consent and COVID-19 tracking apps’ (iapp, 19 May 2020) <https://iapp.org/news/a/illusions-of-consent-and-covid-tracking-apps/> accessed 22 July 2020.

Mark Latonero, ‘Big Data Analytics and Human Rights’ in Molly K Land & Jay D Aronson (eds), New Technologies for Human Rights Law and Practice (Cambridge University Press, 2018) 154-155.

Mark Latonero, ‘Big Data Analytics and Human Rights’ in Molly K Land & Jay D Aronson (eds), New Technologies for Human Rights Law and Practice (Cambridge University Press, 2018) 154-155. https://doi.org/10.1017/9781316838952.007

Ministry of Health, ‘CoronApp – Colombia, the application to know the evolution of the coronavirus in the country’ (Ministry of Health, 7 March 2020) <https://www.minsalud.gov.co/Paginas/CoronApp.aspx> accessed 22 July 2020.

Semana, ‘"La utilidad de CoronApp está en duda": coalición de derechos digitales’ (Semana, 22 May 2020)

<https://www.semana.com/tecnologia/articulo/informe-de-coalicion-de-derechos-digitales-no-ve-utilidad-de-coronapp/673581> accessed 22 July 2020.

Privacy International, ‘Colombia: Coronapp fails at public information purpose’ (Privacy International, 9 March 2020) <https://privacyinternational.org/examples/3435/colombia-coronapp-fails-public-information-purpose> accessed 22 July 2020.

El Ministerio de Technologias, ‘Con descarga de CoronApp Colombia, usuarios de telefonía móvil prepago obtendrán internet y minutos de voz gratis durante un mes’ (Presidencia, 24 April 2020) <https://id.presidencia.gov.co/Paginas/prensa/2020/descarga-CoronApp-Colombia-usuarios-telefonia-movil-prepago-obtendran-internet-minutos-voz-gratis-durante-un-mes-200424.aspx> accessed 22 July 2020.

Las2orillas, ‘La jugadita de Samsung y el gobierno con la aplicación CoronApp‘ (Las Orillas, 23 May 2020) <https://www.las2orillas.co/la-jugadita-de-samsung-y-el-gobierno-con-la-aplicacion-coronapp/> accessed 22 July 2020.

Agencia Nacional Digital <https://and.gov.co/> accessed 22 July 2020.

Agencia Nacional Digital, ‘LA HISTORIA DETRÁS DE CORONAPP’ (Agencia Nacional Digital, 4 May 2020)

<https://and.gov.co/news/la-historia-detras-de-coronapp/> accessed 22 July 2020.

Carolina Botero, ‘CoronApp neither works nor will work’ (Fundación Karisma, 28 June 2020) <https://web.karisma.org.co/coronapp-ni-funciona-ni-funcionara/> accessed 22 July 2020.

AlianzaVerde, ‘Debate a CoronApp sin respuestas": Representante Juanita Goebertus.‘ (Alianza Verde, 16 June 2020) <https://www.alianzaverde.org.co/liderando-congreso/debate-a-coronapp-sin-respuestas-representante-juanita-goebertus> accessed 22 July 2020.

Robert Koch Institut, ‘Disrupt infection chains digitally with the Corona warning app’ (Robert Koch Institut, 17 July 2020) <https://www.rki.de/DE/Content/InfAZ/N/Neuartiges_Coronavirus/WarnApp/Warn_App.html> accessed 22 July 2020.

Dominik Rpzeka, ‘”Run exemplary” Chaos Computer Club praises German Corona app’ (zdfheute, 16 June 2020) < https://www.zdf.de/nachrichten/politik/corona-app-launch-100.html> accessed 22 July 2020).

Tobias M Scholz, ‚Die Konvergenz der Digitalisierung – eine Prognose für Europa‘ in: Christian Scholz, Peter Dörenbächer, and Anne Rennig (eds.) Europa jenseits des Konvergenzparadigmas Divergenz – Dynamik – Diskurs, Nomos (Baden-Baden) 2019, 357-375.

Chaos Computer Club, ‘Corona tracing app: Open letter to the Federal Chancellery and Minister of Health’ (Chaos Computer Club, 24 April 2020) < https://www.ccc.de/de/updates/2020/corona-tracing-app-offener-brief-an-bundeskanzleramt-und-gesundheitsminister> accessed 22 July 2020.

Apple, ‘Privacy-Preserving Contact Tracing‘ <https://www.apple.com/covid19/contacttracing> accessed 22 July 2020.

Chaos Computer Club, ’10 touchstones for the assessment of “Contact Tracing” apps’ (Chaos Computer Club, 6 April 2020) < https://www.ccc.de/de/updates/2020/contact-tracing-requirements> accessed 22 July 2020.

Susanne Höb, ‘Corona app: Chaos Computer Club makes no recommendation’ (Berliner Morgenpost, 30 June 2020) <https://www.morgenpost.de/politik/article229394400/Corona-App-Daten-Sicherheit-Chaos-Computer-Club-Kritik.html> accessed 22 July 2020.

T3N, ‘The government is trolling the CCC with this “nasty trick”’ (T3N, 22 June 2020) <https://t3n.de/news/corona-warn-app-ccc-1293138/> accessed 22 July 2020.

Markus Beckedahl, ‘Much has been done correctly’ (Netzpolitik.org, 15 June 2020) <https://netzpolitik.org/2020/vieles-doch-noch-richtig-gemacht/> accessed 22 July 2020.

YouGov, ‘Pressegrafiken: Corona-Warn-App 17-19 June 2020’ (YouGov, 22 June 2020) <http://www.yougov.de/pressecharts_Corona_Warn_App> accessed 22 July 2020.

Federal Institute for Risk Assessment, ‘A quarter say they use the Corona warning app’ (BfR, 26 June 2020) <https://www.bfr.bund.de/de/presseinformation/2020/23/ein_viertel_gibt_an__die_corona_warn_app_zu_nutzen-248780.html> accessed 22 July 2020.

Andrea Downey, ‘Code for Ireland’s Covid Tracker app given to global public health project’ (Digital Health Net, 23 July 2020) <https://www.digitalhealth.net/2020/07/code-for-irelands-covid-tracker-app-given-to-global-public-health-project/> accessed 23 July 2020.

Oliver Wright and Tom Knowles, ‘Coronavirus app failure leaves tracing plan in disarray’ (The Times, 19 June 2020) < https://www.thetimes.co.uk/edition/news/huge-u-turn-as-virus-tracking-app-is-axed-rf3nh66kq> accessed 22 July 2020.

Laura Donnelly and Mike Wright, ‘NHS coronavirus contract-tracing app ditched in major U-turn’ (The Telegraph, 18 June 2020) <https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2020/06/18/nhs-coronavirus-contact-tracing-app-ditched-major-u-turn/> accessed 22 July 2020.

Reuters, ‘UK PM Johnson vows “world beating” track and trace COVID system by June 1’ (Reuters, 20 May 2020) <https://www.reuters.com/article/us-health-coronavirus-britain-track-idUSKBN22W1MW> accessed 22 July 2020.

Laura Donnelly and Mike Wright, ‘NHS coronavirus contract-tracing app ditched in major U-turn’ (The Telegraph, 18 June 2020) <https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2020/06/18/nhs-coronavirus-contact-tracing-app-ditched-major-u-turn/> accessed 22 July 2020.

There are discrepancies in reporting, with some reports suggesting the figures reached 60 000+ according to Gian Volpicelli, ‘What’s really happening with the NHS Covid-19 app trial’ (Wired, 16 June 2020) <https://www.wired.co.uk/article/contact-tracing-app-isle-of-wight-trial> accessed 22 July 2020.

Matt Burgess, ‘Everything you need to know about the NHS test, track and trace app’ (Wired, 18 June 2020) <https://www.wired.co.uk/article/nhs-covid-19-tracking-app-contact-tracing> accessed 22 July 2020.

Tom Morgan, ‘Isle of Wight contact tracing trial undermined by people on UK mainland downloading the app’ (The Telegraph, 23 May 2020) <https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/0/isle-wight-contact-tracing-trial-undermined-people-uk-mainland/> accessed 22 July 2020.

HL Deb 19 May 2020, vol 803, col 1089.

Gian Volpicelli, ‘What’s really happening with the NHS Covid-19 app trial’ (Wired, 16 June 2020) <https://www.wired.co.uk/article/contact-tracing-app-isle-of-wight-trial> accessed 22 July 2020.

Sonia Jorge, ‘2019 Affordability Report’ (Alliance for Affordable Internet, 2019) <https://a4ai.org/affordability-report/report/2019/> accessed 23 July 2020.

Mercedes Garcia-Escribano, ‘Low Internet Access Driving Inequality’ (International Monetary Fund, 29 June 2020) < https://blogs.imf.org/2020/06/29/low-internet-access-driving-inequality/> accessed 23 July 2020; Pedro Nicolai da Costa, ‘Digital Divide Becomes ‘Chasm’ as Covid-19 Drags On’ (Forbes, 30 June 2020) <https://www.forbes.com/sites/pedrodacosta/2020/06/30/digital-divide-becomes-chasm-as-covid-19-pandemic-drags-on/#66ce82947fba> accessed 22 July 2020.

Zoe Kleinman, ‘Coronavirus: New Covid-19 tracing tool appears on smartphones’ (BBC News, 20 June 2020) <https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-53120290> accessed 22 July 2020.

Leo Kallon, ‘UK virus-tracing app switches to Apple-Google model’ (BBC News, 18 June 2020) <https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-53095336> accessed 22 July 2020.

Mariano Delli Santi, ‘NHSX App Delayed, but Data Protection Still MIA’ (ORG Blog, 23 June 2020) <https://www.openrightsgroup.org/blog/nhsx-app-has-been-delayed-but-data-protection-is-as-urgent-as-ever/> accessed 22 July 2020.

Open Rights Group, ‘Covid-19 and Personal Data: April Briefing’ (ORG, 7 April 2020) <https://www.openrightsgroup.org/publications/covid-19-and-personal-data-april-briefing/> accessed 22 July 2020.

Open Rights Group, ‘Government Admits Test and Trace Unlawful’ (Open Rights Group, 20 July 2020) <https://www.openrightsgroup.org/press-releases/government-admits-test-and-trace-unlawful/> accessed 22 July 2020.

Laurie Clarke, ‘Digital rights group report NHS Test and Trace to ICO, claims legal breach’ (New Statesman, 4 June 2020) <https://tech.newstatesman.com/gdpr/open-rights-group-reports-nhs-test-and-trace-to-ico> accessed 22 July 2020.

Data Protection Act 2018, Schedule 1.

NHS Test and Trace Privacy Information: <https://contact-tracing.phe.gov.uk/help/privacy-notice> accessed 22 July 2020.

Laurie Clarke, ‘Government says no to new privacy legislation for NHSX contact tracing app’ (New Statesman, 22 May 2020) <https://tech.newstatesman.com/gdpr/government-privacy-legislation-nhsx-app> accessed 22 July 2020.

Harriet Harman (22 May 2020) <https://twitter.com/HarrietHarman/status/1263755692655157249?s=20> accessed 22 July 2020; Matt Hancock, ‘COVID-19 Safeguards Bill Letter’ (21 May 2020) <https://committees.parliament.uk/publications/1223/documents/10345/default/> accessed 22 July 2020.

Lilian Edwards and others, ‘The Coronavirus (safeguards) Bill 2020: Proposed Protections for Digital Interventions and in Relation to Immunity Certificates’ (13 April 2020) accessed 22 July 2020.

RT.Com, ‘”Reckless”: Privacy rights group lashes out at UK govt after it admits Covid-19 Test and Trace program didn’t follow legal rules’ (RT.com, 20 July 2020) <https://www.rt.com/uk/495261-privacy-covid19-test-trace-unlawful/> accessed 22 July 2020.

Laurie Clarke, ‘NHS test and trace privacy doc throws doubt on app’s “anonymity” claims’ (New Statesman, 28 May 2020) <https://tech.newstatesman.com/coronavirus/nhs-test-and-trace-privacy-doc-throws-doubt-on-apps-anonymity-claims> accessed 22 July 2020.

Jim Killock (14 July 2020) <https://twitter.com/jimkillock/status/1282961951849684998?s=20> accessed 22 July 2020.

Rowland Manthorpe, ‘Coronavirus: New NHS England contact-tracing app may bring ‘personal benefits’ (Sky News, 22 July 2020) < https://news.sky.com/story/coronavirus-new-nhs-england-contact-tracing-app-will-use-fitbit-style-contact-counts-12033994> accessed 23 July 2020.

Foo Yun Chee, ‘Google offers data pledge in bid to win EU okay for Fitbit buy’ (Reuters, 13 July 2020) <https://uk.reuters.com/article/us-fitbit-m-a-alphabet-eu-exclusive/exclusive-google-offers-data-pledge-in-bid-to-win-eu-okay-for-fitbit-buy-idUKKCN24E2X5> accessed 23 July 2020.

Cory Doctorow, ‘Your Objections to the Google-Fitbit Merger’ (EFF, 25 June 2020) <https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2020/06/your-objections-google-fitbit-merger> accessed 23 July 2020.

Clara Ines Guerrero García, ‘Memorias palenqueras de la libertad’ in Claudia Mosquera Rosero-Labbé and Luiz Claudio Barcelos (eds), Afro-reparaciones: Memorias de la Esclavitud y Justicia Reparativa para negros, afrocolombianos y raizales (Universidad Nacional de Colombia, 2007) 371.

Lilliana Lizarazo-Rodríguez, ‘Constitutional adjudication in Colombia: Avant-garde or Case-law transplant? A literary review’ Estudios Socio-Jurídicos (2011) 13(1), 145, 173.

Toby Miller (2020). The Persistence of Violence. Rutgers, 3.

Matt Burgess, ‘Google got rich from your data, DuckDuckGo is fighting back’ (Wired, 8 June 2020) <https://www.wired.co.uk/article/duckduckgo-android-choice-screen-search> accessed 22 July 2020.

European Commission, ‘Antitrust: Commission fines Google €4.34 billion for illegal practices regarding Android mobile devices to strengthen dominance of Google’s search engine’ 18 July 2018

<https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/IP_18_4581> (accessed 22 July 2020) per Margrethe Vestager.

BBC News, ‘Giant database plan ‘Orwellian’ (BBC News, 15 October 2008) <http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk_politics/7671046.stm?butt=love> accessed 22 July 2020.

International Law Firm Alliance, ‘The legal implications of Contact Tracing in Chile’ (Abdala & CIA Abogados, 29 May 2020) <https://diazreus.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/06/LATAM_contact-tracing.pdf> accessed 22 July 2020.

William Hicks, ‘Thai Covid-19 apps judged invasive’ (Bangkok Post, 20 July 2020) <https://www.bangkokpost.com/business/1954287/thai-covid-19-apps-judged-invasive> accessed 22 July 2020.

Gonzalo Salano, ‘Ecuador uses technology to fight COVID-19’ (AP, 16 April 2020) <https://apnews.com/516d5ddc49e3436c8681356a640c6a46> accessed 22 July 2020.

Emily Sharpe, ‘Using data to fight Covid-19 does not mean lowering the bar for privacy’ (Web Foundation, 15 June 2020) <https://webfoundation.org/2020/06/using-data-to-fight-covid-19-does-not-mean-lowering-the-bar-for-privacy/> accessed 22 July 2020.

Downloads

Published

2020-12-10